Question: Imagine that you are a Catholic living in England in 1745. Would you support the Jacobite movement? Why or why not? Would your thoughts be different if you lived in Ireland? Scotland?

Yes catholic living in England in 1745 would support rebellion du to fact that in that period catholics were second category citizens so catholic would support Jacobite movement and Stuarts who were catholic sypathizers since Charles II, same would do Irish catholic in Scotland main factor here was rather the fact that Stuarts were originally a Scottish house so main factor here would be rather patriotic than religious